Ok let me change the whole concept to something simple. People on the list will not need to be approved. I am against restricting or regulating things and definitely will not allow this site to get bad reputation because of something like that.

So, i will go through the reviews category as well as breeding report category and start compiling a list from there. This is just a generic list that people can use or not use. I think as a community we will benefit from it. Even if 20% of the tarantula hobbyists are on this site they will benefit from it and we will be protected.

Hope it makes sense

Edit: It will be a nice summarised list like the top 100 tarantulas page which will be easier to view instead of going into each forum page. I will like the review page to each breeders page.